Overtime Pay Rules for New York Employers: What the Law Requires

Overtime Pay Rules for New York Employers: What the Law Requires

Time & Attendance | Ally Payroll Insights

Overtime mistakes are among the most common and most expensive payroll errors. The rules are simple on paper, but small details, like how the regular rate is calculated, trip up even careful employers.
This guide covers the core federal rules from the U.S. Department of Labor, plus the 2026 New York figures that apply on Long Island.

Originally published in 2020 as “Fair Labor Standards Act: Overtime Requirements.” Updated November 2026 with current federal and New York figures.

The basic rule

Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, employees who are covered and not exempt must receive overtime pay at no less than one and a half times their regular rate for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. There is no federal limit on the number of hours employees aged 16 and older may work in a week.

New York’s standard is the same. The State Department of Labor describes a standard work week as 40 hours, with anything beyond that paid at one and a half times the regular wage.

The practical takeaway is that overtime is calculated week by week. Payroll needs accurate hours for each employee for each workweek, and the overtime has to be paid on the regular payday for the period in which the wages were earned.

What counts as a workweek

A workweek is a fixed and regularly recurring period of 168 hours, or seven consecutive 24-hour periods. It does not have to match the calendar week and can begin on any day and hour. Different groups of employees may have different workweeks.

Averaging hours across two or more weeks is not permitted. If someone works 50 hours one week and 30 the next, the first week still includes overtime. The FLSA also does not require overtime just because work happens on a weekend or holiday, unless the hours push the week over 40.

Choosing your workweek is a decision worth making on purpose. Many employers pick a Sunday-to-Saturday week for simplicity, but any fixed 168-hour period works as long as you keep it consistent.

How the regular rate works

Overtime is based on the regular rate, not just the base hourly wage. The regular rate includes all pay for the job, except certain payments the law excludes, such as discretionary bonuses and pay for time not worked. Commissions and other earnings count toward it, while discretionary bonuses are left out.

The Department of Labor explains the calculation: divide total pay for the week by the total hours worked. Employees who work at two different rates in one week get a weighted average. A salary for a regular week longer than 40 hours does not satisfy the law on its own. The extra hours still earn overtime.

For example, an employee hired to work 45 hours a week for a fixed weekly salary of $405 has a regular rate of $9.00, and still earns an additional half-time premium for the 5 overtime hours. That is an example straight from the Department of Labor, and it shows why a fixed salary alone does not settle the question.

Exempt and non-exempt employees

Some salaried employees are exempt, but being paid a salary is not enough. To qualify under the executive, administrative, or professional exemptions, employees must meet the duties tests and earn at least $684 per week, which is $35,568 per year, under the current federal level.

New York sets its own minimum wage, which is $17.00 per hour on Long Island in 2026 and remains $17.00 in 2027. Review each position carefully, since an exemption has to hold up under the rules that apply to it.

Mistakes that cost employers

Overtime cannot be waived by agreement. An employer policy that says no overtime unless approved does not erase the duty to pay for hours actually worked. Flat sums paid for overtime work, regardless of hours, also may not count as the overtime premium.

Accurate time records are your best protection. Our time and attendance tools collect hours from time clocks, POS systems, and mobile apps and apply overtime rules before payroll runs.

Employers can also run into trouble when overtime depends on a manager approving it. Hours worked still have to be paid whether or not they were approved, so the better fix is a system that flags overtime before the week ends.

Keeping clean records

The best defense against an overtime claim is a clean record of hours worked. Capture start and stop times automatically wherever possible, require employees to review their time before each pay period closes, and have supervisors approve exceptions in writing.

Keep pay records organized by workweek so you can show exactly how each overtime payment was calculated. If a question comes up months later, you want to be able to answer it in minutes, not days.

Connecting your timekeeping directly to payroll removes retyping, which is where many errors start. It also lets you spot overtime building up during the week, while there is still time to adjust schedules.

Get overtime right every pay period

If you are not sure your system handles overtime the way the law requires, it is worth having someone check.

Request a free quote and we will review how you track hours and calculate overtime.

FAQ

Common Questions

For covered, non-exempt employees, overtime is owed at one and a half times the regular rate for every hour over 40 in a workweek.

No. The Department of Labor says averaging hours over two or more weeks is not permitted. Each workweek stands alone.

Not by itself. The employee must also meet the duties tests and earn at least $684 per week under the federal rule.

$17.00 per hour in 2026, and it stays at $17.00 in 2027, according to the New York State Department of Labor.

Free Quote

Ready to Hand Off Your Payroll?

Tell us about your business and a representative will be in touch with you promptly.