Workers' Compensation | Ally Payroll Insights
With a traditional policy, the insurer sets your premium at the start of the policy year using an estimate of your payroll. The New York State Insurance Fund explains that billed premium is based on the payroll estimate you provide at the beginning, which is how premiums are calculated across the industry.
At the end of the year, the insurer audits your actual payroll. If you paid more than you estimated, you owe additional premium. If you paid less, you get premium back. The industry rating bureau confirms the policy allows the audit and review of records during the term and up to three years afterward.
That is not a flaw in the system. It is simply how the product is designed. The trouble is that a small business with a changing payroll can end up with a premium that does not match its real exposure for most of the year.
Estimates are guesses. If your business grows, adds seasonal staff, or gives raises, your real payroll can land well above the estimate and the audit bill arrives all at once. If you underestimated on purpose to keep premium low, the audit usually catches it.
Missed audits make things worse. NYSIF notes that when records are missing or appointments are missed, it may issue an estimated audit, which can produce a premium higher than it should be.
With pay-as-you-go, premium is calculated on the payroll you actually ran in each cycle and collected along with payroll. There is no large estimated deposit, and your premium moves up and down with your real headcount and wages.
That means a slow month costs less, a busy month costs more, and the year-end audit has far fewer surprises because the numbers have been reported all along. Our workers’ comp pay-as-you-go program is built this way, using the payroll data we already process for you.
Because the premium is reported with each payroll, it is also easier to see what workers’ comp actually costs per employee and per dollar of wages. That visibility helps when you are pricing a job, budgeting for a new hire, or deciding whether to bring in seasonal help.
The Workers’ Compensation Board treats most people who work for a for-profit business as employees, including part-time, seasonal, and unpaid family members. Those workers need coverage.
The penalties for going without are steep. A civil penalty can be up to $2,000 for each 10-day period without coverage, and by the time a first penalty notice arrives it can pass $12,000. Failing to secure coverage for five or fewer employees is a misdemeanor with a fine of $1,000 to $5,000, and for more than five employees it is a class E felony with a fine of $5,000 to $50,000. An uninsured employer also becomes responsible for wage and medical benefits awarded on a claim.
Coverage also has to be right on paper. The Board monitors the coverage status of every employer subject to the law, and if it has no coverage information for a period it will mail an inquiry notice asking you to prove you are compliant. Businesses have 30 days from the first penalty notice to request a review.
It tends to fit businesses with payroll that changes through the year, such as restaurants, contractors, retailers, and growing teams. It also helps owners who would rather not tie up cash in a deposit.
A few questions to ask: Do you know your real payroll by class of work? Does your premium follow your actual payroll? Is your coverage tied to payroll records that are accurate and organized for an audit?
Whether you stay with a traditional policy or move to pay-as-you-go, ask the same questions. How is premium calculated, and on what payroll? When will you be audited, and how are the results reported to me? What records will you ask for? What happens if my headcount changes mid-year?
Also ask who will handle your classification codes. Insurers review your operations at audit, and if your business changes, your classification can change with it. Each classification has its own rate per $100 of payroll, so getting the right code matters as much as getting the payroll right.
A provider who answers these questions clearly, in writing, is one you can plan around.
Workers’ comp does not have to be a source of surprise bills. When premium follows payroll, you can plan around it.
Talk to our team about coverage that tracks your payroll. Request a free quote and we will walk through your options.
FAQ
It is a billing arrangement where premium is calculated on the actual payroll for each pay period, instead of on an estimate made at the start of the year.
Insurers can still verify payroll, but because actual payroll is reported all year, there are usually fewer surprises at the end.
You can face civil penalties of up to $2,000 per 10-day period without coverage, criminal fines, and responsibility for any claim awarded to an injured employee.
The Workers’ Compensation Board considers most people who provide services to a for-profit business to be employees, including part-time, seasonal, and unpaid workers.
Free Quote
Tell us about your business and a representative will be in touch with you promptly.